Sep 20, 2018
AT&T says Justice Department failed to show price hikes from Time Warner merger
WASHINGTON — Fighting to defend its $81 billion takeover of Time Warner from a government challenge, AT&T is arguing the Trump Justice Department has failed to show that the merger will raise prices for pay-TV programming and for the consumers who watch it.
The AT&T-Time Warner marriage was completed this spring soon after a federal judge approved it. But government antitrust regulators filed to have the judge's ruling overturned, setting the stage for a landmark competition case in the U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington.
In a filing Thursday, the phone and pay-TV giant asserted the merger will save it money on content from Time Warner's Turner Broadcasting, enabling it to cut charges to its DirecTV customers by at least $78 million a year.
U.S. District Judge Richard Leon was correct to dismiss the government's argument that the merger would hurt competition, limit choices and jack up prices for consumers to stream TV and movies, Dallas-based AT&T, the biggest pay-TV provider in the U.S., said in its filing.
The government "failed for multiple reasons to (show) that net retail prices will likely be higher than otherwise," the company said.
Leon's ruling in June opened the way for one of the biggest media deals ever. AT&T has since absorbed Time Warner, the owner of CNN, HBO, the Warner Bros. movie studio, "Game of Thrones," coveted sports programming and other "must-see" shows.
The Justice Department, however, has maintained that Leon was wrong in concluding the merger won't harm consumers and that he misunderstood the complexities of the booming pay-TV market and the nature of AT&T's competitors.
If the government were to prevail in its appeal, the complex merger might have to be unwound.
Many legal experts believe the government will have a hard time convincing the appeals court to overturn Leon's ruling. Opposing the merger forced the federal antitrust regulators to argue against standing legal doctrine that favors mergers among companies that don't compete directly with each other, what's known as a vertical merger.
The U.S. antitrust lawsuit against AT&T was the first time in decades that the government has challenged that doctrine by suing to block a vertical merger.
The government contends that this deal is different. By combining the programming content of Time Warner's Turner Broadcasting with AT&T's vast distribution network for its DirecTV, the combination will hurt competition and violate federal law, it says. AT&T claims about 25 million of the 90 million or so U.S. households that are pay-TV customers.
Even with a small chance of the government winning, the stakes are high and the case could affect the future course of antitrust regulation.
When the deal was first made public in October 2016, it drew fire from then-candidate Donald Trump, who promised to kill it "because it's too much concentration of power in the hands of too few." Trump has publicly feuded with Time Warner's CNN, calling it "failing" and a purveyor of "fake news." The president's statements didn't come up during the trial, though his antipathy loomed in the background.
Leon's ruling opened the floodgates to deal making in the fast-changing worlds of entertainment production and distribution.
Just a day after his decision, Comcast launched a $65 billion cash bid for the bulk of 21st Century Fox — topping Disney's all-stock $52.5 billion offer in December. Comcast later dropped that bid in order to focus on its attempted buyout of European pay-TV operator Sky.
After months of offers and counteroffers for Sky by Comcast and Fox, the two U.S. media empires will settle their battle for control of the European broadcaster through a rare auction. The auction will begin after the London stock market's close on Friday and end sometime Saturday evening.
Disney, meanwhile, is closing in on a $71 billion acquisition of Fox's entertainment assets.
Other rumored or potential deals include a Verizon bid for CBS and a tie-up of Sprint and T-Mobile.
“Heal,” a documentary from Princess Kate on her cancer diagnosis and living life in the face of serious illness, will debut in the U.K. on Nov. 29, with international premieres to follow. The documentary will premiere on the BBC in the U.K. on Nov. 29, via NBCUniversal in the United States on Nov. 30, Channel […]
Kate Middleton is starring in her first documentary, and it’s a personal one. Heal, which will premiere on the BBC in the UK on November 29 and NBC in the U.S. on November 30, follows the Princess of Wales as she undertakes the National Three Peaks Challenge and reflects on her life as a cancer […]
For Egyptian filmmaker Sara Shazli, the camera became a way of asking her mother questions she had carried since childhood. Returning to Cairo from film school in Cuba, she would wait in the family kitchen, camera in hand, hoping to understand the woman whose devotion to cinema had so often left her feeling alone. “Was […]
French filmmaker Julie Bertuccelli, whose “The Tree” closed the Cannes Film Festival in 2010, said her planned adaptation of Henning Mankell’s novel “Italian Shoes” fell apart after a Canadian producer “stole the film” from her, and that she plans to shoot her next feature in India. Bertuccelli was speaking at “From Witness to Change: The […]
The life and legacy of legendary Egyptian artist Mohamed Mounir is set to be explored in a biopic spearheaded by The Film Committee at Media City Qatar. The Film Committee has acquired the rights to document Mounir’s life story, with partners on the project set to include a leading regional studio and other partners, which […]
Qatar’s Film Committee and Watermelon Pictures have announced a strategic partnership to develop and co-produce a slate of films “championing visionary filmmakers and compelling stories from the Global South and beyond with an emphasis on culturally authentic storytelling and broad international appeal,” they said in a statement. The Global South is a geopolitical and economic […]
Marion Cotillard, who serves as the jury president at this year’s Marrakech Film Festival, says she prefers watching films with “as little information as possible.” “I don’t know anything about the movies we’re gonna see, I haven’t seen a single image,” the Oscar-winning French actress said at the festival’s jury press conference on Saturday morning. […]
Indian auteur Girish Kasaravalli looked back on his career in Kannada-language cinema at the 57th International Film Festival of India (IFFI) in Goa, in a masterclass titled “The Moral Universe of Parallel Cinema: 50 Years of Girish Kasaravalli.” The 75-year-old spoke about the moral contradictions of society and the relationship between cinematic form and social […]
Steven Paul, a special advisor to President Donald Trump who has lobbied for a U.S. federal tax credit alongside special ambassador to Hollywood Jon Voight, said he hopes the incentive will be “active” in some form by January 2027. Speaking at the Doha Industry Days – the industry component of the Doha Film Festival – […]
Lana Del Rey and Dua Lipa add tracks to the cinematic video game, Julien Baker chases love and more.
“I really feel like I can taste water now in a way that I didn’t used to be able to,” says the actress, now starring in “The Good Daughter.”
These shows full of wholesome recipes, nature walks and compelling audio fiction will help see you through to winter’s arrival.