For Jussie Smollett, 1 story equals 16 felony counts

Mar 10, 2019

A grand jury's 16-count indictment against Jussie Smollett might be the result of prosecutors looking to charge the "Empire" actor for individual lies they contend he told about the night he says he was attacked by two masked men

CHICAGO — News that a grand jury had indicted "Empire" actor Jussie Smollett for allegedly lying to Chicago police about being attacked by two masked men may not have made much of a splash except for one thing: The lone felony count that Smollett had been arrested on last month had turned into 16.

The reasons Smollett is facing 16 counts rather than just one count of disorderly conduct — the felony in Illinois that people are charged with when accused of lying to police — are not fully explained in the indictment that a grand jury returned Thursday. But legal experts say indictments like that aren't uncommon in Chicago, and there are some explanations as to how the grand jury could have arrived at the 16 counts, eight of them for Smollett's comments to a police officer and eight others for what he told a detective.

The first starts with something that has been apparent since Chicago police Superintendent Eddie Johnson briefed reporters last month on the investigation: Authorities are angry at Smollett.

"What you have is a police department and prosecutors that are obviously mad at him for embarrassing the city so they took every one of his lies and made it into another count," said Terry Sullivan, a prominent local attorney who as a young prosecutor helped convict serial killer John Wayne Gacy in 1980 of killing 33 young men.

Smollett's attorney, Mark Geragos, called the 16-count indictment "prosecutorial overkill." But prominent Chicago defense attorney Joseph Lopez, who is not involved in the Smollett case, said it's the way prosecutors in Chicago do business.

"It is common practice for the Cook County state's attorney to charge as much as they can for any kind of crime," he said.

A former state appellate judge suggested such a strategy might be employed by prosecutors trying to protect themselves from the possibility that a jury or a judge might believe some, but not all, of the allegations.

"If you only charge him with one or two counts and they find him not guilty of them, you're done," said David Erickson, who now teaches at Chicago Kent College of Law. "This gives the prosecution the ability to convict him of any one of these lies."

Lopez said it appears that when prosecutors went to the grand jury they simply dissected the case, breaking Smollett's account into each of its individual pieces and accused him of one count per detail they believe he made up.

That means that one count might stem from Smollett's contention that the men hurled racial and homophobic taunts at him and another for what he said was the way they beat him. Another could be tied to his claim that the men doused him with an unknown chemical and another still for his statement that one of them looped a rope tied like a noose around his neck. Then there was his assertion, police said, that he could see one of the men was white because he could see the skin around his eyes. The two men police say Smollett hired to take part in the attack are both black.

"The lies add up pretty fast," Lopez said.

Another explanation for the multiple counts is that perhaps Smollett gave multiple statements to the police, meaning that individual counts represent separate interviews with police.

Each count is a Class 4 felony, which carries a possible prison sentence of one to three years. If Smollett is convicted, a judge could allow him to be given probation instead of imposing a prison sentence.

Lopez and Erickson agreed that if Smollett is convicted, it won't matter whether it's on one or several counts when it comes to sentencing. That's because he would be sentenced for only one of them.

"If you add them all up it's still only one crime," Erickson said. "That's just how it is."

And Lopez said that if Smollett is convicted of multiple counts, prosecutors can ask that the sentences be served consecutively but it is highly unlikely a judge would do so.

Smollett's legal troubles may not begin and end with this one indictment. Days before the Jan. 29 incident, a letter threatening Smollett was sent to the studio where the television show is filmed — a letter Johnson told reporters the day Smollett appeared in court that the actor had actually sent.

The FBI, which is investigating that letter, has declined to comment on the investigation. But if Smollett did talk to the FBI, depending on what he said, he could be in more legal trouble.

"Lying to the FBI is a crime," said Erickson.

Smollett is scheduled to appear in court on Thursday, where he will likely enter a formal plea to the 16 counts.

"Jussie adamantly maintains his innocence even if law enforcement has robbed him of that presumption," Geragos, his attorney, said.

___

Check out the AP's complete coverage  of the Jussie Smollett case.

More News

‘GTA Flu’ Has Schools and Jobs Bracing for Sick Days
Nov 19, 2026
‘GTA Flu’ Has Schools and Jobs Bracing for Sick Days

The highly anticipated release of Grand Theft Auto VI is expected to prompt a wave of students and employees to stay home on Thursday.

Newsmax Fears Fox Freeze-Out on Roku if Merger Is Not Blocked
Nov 19, 2026
Newsmax Fears Fox Freeze-Out on Roku if Merger Is Not Blocked

Newsmax filed an antitrust lawsuit on Thursday that seeks to block the Fox-Roku merger, arguing that the deal gives Fox unlawful monopoly power over the free streaming market. Fox Corp. closed the $22 billion acquisition earlier this month. The Department of Justice cleared the deal the same day, announcing that Fox had made commitments to […]

National Book Award for Nonfiction Goes to Writer Denied Visa to Attend
Nov 19, 2026
National Book Award for Nonfiction Goes to Writer Denied Visa to Attend

The author Abdelrahman ElGendy received one of the major American prizes for nonfiction in absentia for his memoir, “Huna.” Hannah Lillith Assadi won the fiction prize.

Rob Lowe Defends Taking Role in Ben Shapiro’s ‘Confession’ Movie: ‘Why Wouldn’t I?’
Nov 19, 2026
Rob Lowe Defends Taking Role in Ben Shapiro’s ‘Confession’ Movie: ‘Why Wouldn’t I?’

Rob Lowe is responding to backlash over his role in a controversial new movie. The 62-year-old actor stars in the […] The post Rob Lowe Defends Taking Role in Ben Shapiro’s ‘Confession’ Movie: ‘Why Wouldn’t I?’ appeared first on Just Jared - Celebrity News, Entertainment News & Photos.

Tell Us About Your Sunday Routine, And We'll Assign You A "Sex And The City" Character?
Nov 19, 2026
Tell Us About Your Sunday Routine, And We'll Assign You A "Sex And The City" Character?

Are you a Carrie, Samantha, Charlotte, or Miranda? View Entire Post ›

Tim McGraw’s Daughters Audrey & Maggie Make Rare Red Carpet Appearance
Nov 19, 2026
Tim McGraw’s Daughters Audrey & Maggie Make Rare Red Carpet Appearance

Tim McGraw was happy to just see his daughters smile at the 2026 CMA Awards. The “I Like It, I Love It” singer was joined by his and wife Faith Hill’s daughters Maggie, 28, and Audrey, 24, for the...

Taylor Swift Has Surprise Guest for First CMAs Performance in 13 Years
Nov 19, 2026
Taylor Swift Has Surprise Guest for First CMAs Performance in 13 Years

The CMAs knew Taylor Swift, they knew her.   And now, they have gotten to know her again as the singer took the stage to perform at the Country Music Association Awards Nov. 18 in her first CMAs...

‘The Lowdown’ Season 2 Episode 7 Recap: Meat Grinder
Nov 19, 2026
‘The Lowdown’ Season 2 Episode 7 Recap: Meat Grinder

This week the series features Lee at his best and shows off its remarkable emotional range.

Taylor Swift Performs ‘I Knew It, I Knew You’ & ‘Our Song’ at CMAs 2026!
Nov 19, 2026
Taylor Swift Performs ‘I Knew It, I Knew You’ & ‘Our Song’ at CMAs 2026!

Taylor Swift is back on the CMAs stage for the first time in over a decade! The 36-year-old two-time CMA […] The post Taylor Swift Performs ‘I Knew It, I Knew You’ & ‘Our Song’ at CMAs 2026! appeared first on Just Jared - Celebrity News, Entertainment News & Photos.

Larry Poindexter Dies: ‘S.W.A.T.’, ‘JAG’ & ‘Days Of Our Lives’ Actor Was 66
Nov 19, 2026
Larry Poindexter Dies: ‘S.W.A.T.’, ‘JAG’ & ‘Days Of Our Lives’ Actor Was 66

Larry Poindexter, a veteran character actor who has appeared in almost 200 movies and TV series, passed away today, Nov. 18, four and a half days after being hit by a car. He was 66. Poindexter was struck while crossing the street to pick up food in his Studio City neighborhood Friday night. He had […]

Ella Langley Leads The Pack Among Early CMA Award Winners
Nov 19, 2026
Ella Langley Leads The Pack Among Early CMA Award Winners

Ella Langley has taken five CMA Awards so far, including Single of the Year, Music Video of the Year and Song of the Year for “Choosin’ Texas,” and Album of the Year for Dandelion. She also got Female Vocalist of the Year, as the Country Music Association revealed its winners at the full ceremony tonight. […]

"I Can Excuse Racism, But I Draw The Line At Character Assassination": People Are Calling Out 28 TV Characters Whose Arcs Were Absolutely Ruined By The End Of Their Shows
Nov 19, 2026
"I Can Excuse Racism, But I Draw The Line At Character Assassination": People Are Calling Out 28 TV Characters Whose Arcs Were Absolutely Ruined By The End Of Their Shows

"She goes from a strong and funny female character to a pathetic, murdering, coked-out loser who wants to commit incest with her own brother." View Entire Post ›

NEWSLETTER
Reporter Pass

Bringing you to an exciting adventure to get the exclusive inside scoop on the latest celebrities news. Reporter Pass is the only access you need to get into Hollywood.