TV Review: Non-live Fox 'Rent' is 'No day but yesterday'

Jan 28, 2019

TV Review: Non-live Fox 'Rent' is a fiasco. Unable to recover from a star's injury it became 'No day but yesterday'

NEW YORK — Fox's live broadcast of the rock musical "Rent" had a chance to show off the flexibility and work ethic of Broadway in the face of a setback — and completely blew it.

The musical about people living and dying in poverty with AIDS was unable to overcome a simple foot injury to one of its stars, scrapping the idea of going live and relying on prerecorded footage.

Producers promised the show would go on but it really didn't. The majority of the dress rehearsal from the night before was broadcast instead of really live. This is the very opposite of the show's ethic "no day but today."

The creators were unable to respond to Brennin Hunt's broken foot, even though examples from Broadway abound, including Andy Karl finishing a preview of "Groundhog Day" with the use of a cane in 2017 after tearing his anterior cruciate ligament. He was onstage when the show officially opened just 72 hours later.

The decision Sunday left the "Rent" cast marooned on Stage 16 on the Fox lot in Los Angeles until the finale, a disastrous idea that rightfully incensed anyone who loves live theater. To be honest, even in rehearsal, the show lacked sustained sparks, despite an overenthusiastic audience.

The rock musical, by Jonathan Larson and inspired by the Giacomo Puccini opera "La Boheme," celebrates survival among the artists and homeless of New York's East Village in the early 1990s. Jason Sherwood's sets were messy, scaffolding-heavy spaces with little beauty, except the lovely Christmas tree made of recycled materials. Realistic snow fell, but the musical's gritty language was excised.

The show shared DNA with the original 1996 Broadway production, including original director Michael Greif and original costume designer Angela Wendt. Original Broadway cast-members — including Idina Menzel, Anthony Rapp and Taye Diggs — also showed up for a rollicking reprise of "Seasons of Love," singing beside their successors, a very nice touch.

Tinashe nailed an awesome "Out Tonight" and was a great Mimi Marquez, but Jordan Fisher initially seemed overmatched by playing Mark Cohen, though he rose to the occasion by the end. Hunt successfully lit live candles during rehearsal and showed ability to hit his marks despite his bandaged foot while live but otherwise played his Roger with as much honesty as a hunky villain in a Disney Chanel teen show.

Brandon Victor Dixon sparkled as Tom Collins, proving again to be a supremely natural live performer. (He was an awesome Judas in "Jesus Christ Superstar Live" and should be in every live broadcast show from now on, providing they are truly live.) Valentina from "RuPaul's Drag Race" was a fine Angel Dumott Schunard but often lacked the nuance her doomed role requires.

Vanessa Hudgens deserves credit for just considering the role of Maureen Johnson — and doing the insane, manic "Over the Moon" — but did really well, particularly in the duet "Take Me or Leave Me." Menzel, who originated the role, has nothing to fear about her legacy but kudos for Hudgens. And Keala Settle helped make the iconic "Seasons of Love" a highlight.

The heartbreaking choral "Will I" was done with understated beauty — with audience members holding candles — and the big "La Vie Boheme" was a complex, if overly long, success. "Without You" movingly reminded us of the horror of AIDS. Creators clearly wanted to make the AIDS crisis more visceral but they took questionable liberties with the text and that's not cool at all.

Choreographer Sonya Tayeh's eclectic touches throughout were welcome (Angel's death scene was an awesome foggy fever dream) and Wendt's designs were flashy and grubby at the same time. (A cute touch was reflecting Anthony Rapp's original multicolored scarf with Fisher's striped sweater.)

The production is part of broadcast TV's ongoing fascination with theater musicals, which kicked off in 2013 with NBC's "The Sound of Music Live!" and includes such entries like "The Wiz Live!" and Fox's "Grease Live!"

Their fate seemed to be in danger following the poorly rated 2017 production of "A Christmas Story Live!" but last Easter's telecast of "Jesus Christ Superstar Live in Concert" was critically acclaimed and seemed to stem the ratings slide. But being live is not just important to this endeavor. It is at its very foundation — and "Rent" failed the test.

Break a leg, indeed.

___

Mark Kennedy is at http://twitter.com/KennedyTwits

More News

Sundance-Winning ‘Cactus Pears’ Producer’s Delhi Beauty Salon Comedy-Drama ‘Nisa’ Bows at India’s WAVES Film Bazaar
Nov 20, 2026
Sundance-Winning ‘Cactus Pears’ Producer’s Delhi Beauty Salon Comedy-Drama ‘Nisa’ Bows at India’s WAVES Film Bazaar

Chicago-based filmmaker Ambarien Alqadar is taking her debut feature “Nisa,” a Hindi-Urdu comedy-drama about a young divorcee working at her mother’s beauty salon in Delhi, to the Co-Production Market at WAVES Film Bazaar 2026. The project evolved out of a documentary exploration of the world Alqadar grew up in. The feature screenplay was developed at […]

DANNA & EMJAY’s ‘Moreno Fantasy RMX’ Lyrics & Meaning Explained: Watch Their New Music Video
Nov 20, 2026
DANNA & EMJAY’s ‘Moreno Fantasy RMX’ Lyrics & Meaning Explained: Watch Their New Music Video

DANNA and EMJAY are teaming up for a hot new Latin pop collaboration! The two Mexican singers released “Moreno Fantasy […] The post DANNA & EMJAY’s ‘Moreno Fantasy RMX’ Lyrics & Meaning Explained: Watch Their New Music Video appeared first on Just Jared - Celebrity News, Entertainment News & Photos.

Climate Displacement Drama ‘The River Without a Bridge’ Heads to India’s WAVES Film Bazaar Co-Production Market
Nov 20, 2026
Climate Displacement Drama ‘The River Without a Bridge’ Heads to India’s WAVES Film Bazaar Co-Production Market

Director Praveen Morchhale is taking “The River Without a Bridge,” a family drama about a young girl uprooted by a climate disaster, to the Co-Production Market at WAVES Film Bazaar 2026. Told in the Assamese, Bangla, Burmese and Hindi languages, the film follows 7-year-old Aliya, who hasn’t spoken since the disaster forced her family out […]

Maharaja Ranjit Singh, the Sikh Ruler Known as ‘Sher-e-Punjab,’ Gets Biopic, Plans 2027 Shoot (EXCLUSIVE)
Nov 20, 2026
Maharaja Ranjit Singh, the Sikh Ruler Known as ‘Sher-e-Punjab,’ Gets Biopic, Plans 2027 Shoot (EXCLUSIVE)

Maharaja Ranjit Singh, the 19th-century Sikh ruler known as the “Sher-e-Punjab,” or Lion of Punjab, is getting a big-screen biopic, with Katha Studios and B4 Makers Studios partnering on a film that will go into production in 2027. The two banners are pitching the project as a sweeping theatrical epic. It will trace the ruler’s […]

Jennifer Lopez Takes Off Jacket to Reveal See-Through Dress at ‘The JLo Show’ L.A. Premiere
Nov 20, 2026
Jennifer Lopez Takes Off Jacket to Reveal See-Through Dress at ‘The JLo Show’ L.A. Premiere

Jennifer Lopez is flaunting some skin in a sheer dress at the premiere of her Las Vegas concert special! The […] The post Jennifer Lopez Takes Off Jacket to Reveal See-Through Dress at ‘The JLo Show’ L.A. Premiere appeared first on Just Jared - Celebrity News, Entertainment News & Photos.

Jennifer Lawrence Ranks Her Onscreen Kisses, Details ‘New’ Implants and Says Her ‘Hunger Games’ Bow and Arrow Was ‘Stolen’ in Andy Cohen Interview
Nov 20, 2026
Jennifer Lawrence Ranks Her Onscreen Kisses, Details ‘New’ Implants and Says Her ‘Hunger Games’ Bow and Arrow Was ‘Stolen’ in Andy Cohen Interview

Jennifer Lawrence wasn’t afraid to spill tea during her appearance on the Nov. 19 episode of “Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen.” She appeared alongside her “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” co-star Josh Hutcherson and, in her trademark honesty, fielded plenty of questions, ranging from her on-screen roles to her opinion of […]

Comment your favorite color, and we'll tell you which Panem district you belong in.
Nov 20, 2026
Comment your favorite color, and we'll tell you which Panem district you belong in.

May odds be ever in your favor. View Entire Post ›

Are Katie & Victor from ‘The Traitors: New Blood’ Dating? Finalists Reveal Where They Stand After Finale
Nov 20, 2026
Are Katie & Victor from ‘The Traitors: New Blood’ Dating? Finalists Reveal Where They Stand After Finale

Katie Fites and Victor Vollbrechthausen had a flirty relationship while competing against each other on The Traitors: New Blood. During […] The post Are Katie & Victor from ‘The Traitors: New Blood’ Dating? Finalists Reveal Where They Stand After Finale appeared first on Just Jared - Celebrity News, Entertainment News & Photos.

‘War’ Season 2 Cast Shakeup: 6 Actors Confirmed to Return, 2 Definitely Exiting, & Many New Leads Revealed!
Nov 20, 2026
‘War’ Season 2 Cast Shakeup: 6 Actors Confirmed to Return, 2 Definitely Exiting, & Many New Leads Revealed!

The HBO series War just wrapped its first season and the second season has already been filmed! Season 1 follows […] The post ‘War’ Season 2 Cast Shakeup: 6 Actors Confirmed to Return, 2 Definitely Exiting, & Many New Leads Revealed! appeared first on Just Jared - Celebrity News, Entertainment News & Photos.

‘Sunrise On The Reaping’ Epilogue Scene Explained: How Everything Ties Together
Nov 20, 2026
‘Sunrise On The Reaping’ Epilogue Scene Explained: How Everything Ties Together

SPOILER ALERT: This post spoils the end of The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. The epilogue scene at the end of The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping echoes the chapter that closes Suzanne Collins’ novel of the same name. Woody Harrelson, Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson appear in the final moment of the […]

‘Project 11,’ Shot by 11 Directors in 11 Global Cities, Returns on Oh Short Flips (EXCLUSIVE)
Nov 20, 2026
‘Project 11,’ Shot by 11 Directors in 11 Global Cities, Returns on Oh Short Flips (EXCLUSIVE)

“Project 11,” a 2011 survival thriller made by 11 directors working remotely from 11 cities, will be re-released Nov. 26 as the first title under Oh Short Flips’ new Classic Shorts vertical. The short pits 11 gamers in 11 cities against one another. Each has 11 minutes to live, and only the final survivor wins. […]

Bowen Yang Under Fire for Antisemitic Remark About Regina Spektor: ‘Incredibly Disappointing’
Nov 20, 2026
Bowen Yang Under Fire for Antisemitic Remark About Regina Spektor: ‘Incredibly Disappointing’

"Well done buying this hate mongering podcast [Disney]," Meghan McCain writes about the “Las Culturistas” co-host The post Bowen Yang Under Fire for Antisemitic Remark About Regina Spektor: ‘Incredibly Disappointing’ appeared first on TheWrap.

NEWSLETTER
Reporter Pass

Bringing you to an exciting adventure to get the exclusive inside scoop on the latest celebrities news. Reporter Pass is the only access you need to get into Hollywood.